The tomatoes I planted last spring have been late bloomers this year; we’re just starting to enjoy the fruits of the harvest. It’s been a part time job figuring out what to do with them all. I’ve given some away, I’ll can others, and have been churning out tomato-centric dishes of every stripe: eggplant and tomato gratin, tomato and cucumber salad, BLTs rolled up in whole wheat tortillas for lunch, and bare naked sliced tomatoes with flaky salt.

Because of all the care and patience that went into acquiring these beauties, they can’t just go into any old recipe. I’m like the parent who demands their child admittance to the Ivy League of preschools; my tomatoes can’t just land any old place.

Garden Plum Tomatoes

This Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce is certainly a good place to land. It’s inspired by a dish at Scarpetta, a restaurant in New York City that has built a reputation almost entirely on this pasta. When my sister, who lives in New York, began riffing on their  famous dish, I was skeptical that it could possibly match the real deal. But she convinced me that it was worth gambling my small storehouse of tomatoes on a homespun version.

This Spaghetti with Tomato Basil sauce is a strangely simple recipe that’s become a  “go to” for company, particularly when picky children are involved. It presents as little more than pasta and tomato sauce (a dish few kids will refuse), yet meets the demands of more sophisticated palates. Plus, all of the work can be done up front, so you can mingle with your company instead of sweating at the stove. And though my dining room lacks the buzz of a New York City restaurant, the pasta is (very, nearly, almost) “that good.”

Best Tomato Basil Pasta inspired by Scarpetta - Mom's Kitchen Handbook
5 from 2 votes

Scarpetta Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce

This simple, addictive pasta is made up of two parts: 1) tomatoes that have been peeled, seeded, and then mashed as they bubble gently on the stove 2) garlic- and basil-infused olive oil that gets drizzled on just before serving. When making this pasta when tomatoes are no longer in season, I take a page from Jaden Hair of Steamy Kitchen and substitute one 12-ounce can of San Marzano tomatoes plus four fresh plum tomatoes (peeled and seeded) in place of the 25 fresh ones. Using canned also has the upside of cutting down significantly on labor.

Course Dinner
Cuisine Italian
Prep Time 25 minutes
Cook Time 30 minutes
Total Time 55 minutes
Calories 411 kcal
Author katiemorford


  • 25 ripe plum tomatoes
  • ¼ cup plus 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil, divided
  • 2 pinches crushed red pepper, divided
  • Salt to taste
  • Freshly ground black pepper to taste
  • 1 large sprig fresh basil, plus 8 chopped fresh basil leaves
  • 6 large cloves garlic, peeled and smashed
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • ½ cup grated Parmesan, plus more to pass at the table
  • 1 pound spaghetti


Make the Sauce

  1. Peel the tomatoes by plunging them into boiling water for 10 to 15 seconds. Use a slotted spoon to lift them from the water and immerse them into a large bowl of ice water. Slip the skins off the tomatoes with the aid of a paring knife, if needed. Trim out the little bit of core and cut the tomatoes in half. Use your fingers to scoop out the seeds. Put the tomatoes in a bowl to catch all the juices.

  2. Heat 2 tablespoons of the olive oil in your biggest sauté pan over medium-high heat. Add tomatoes with their juices and a pinch of crushed red pepper. Season lightly with salt and pepper. Cook for a couple of minutes, and then use a potato masher to break them up. Do this periodically as they cook until the tomatoes are tender, and the liquid reduced, about 20 to 25 minutes. This should result in about 2 1/2 cups of sauce and can be made ahead of time and stored in the refrigerator.

Make the Garlic Basil Oil

  1. While the tomatoes cook, make the garlic basil oil. In a saucepan, combine the remaining ¼ cup of olive oil, garlic, 1 sprig of basil, and a generous pinch of crushed red pepper. Cook over low heat for 15 minutes to infuse the oil with flavor. Remove from heat and allow it steep until just before serving. Then, drain the oil through a sieve or fine strainer into a small bowl.

Assemble the Dish

  1. To finish the dish, bring a large, generously salted pot of water to a boil over high heat. Cook the spaghetti until al dente, scooping out about 1/2 cup of pasta water before draining. 

  2. Add the spaghetti to the pan of tomatoes. Add the chopped basil, butter, and Parmesan cheese. Gently toss until the pasta is evenly coated with the sauce. If the pasta looks like it could use a little moisture, add pasta water, a tablespoon at time, until nicely sauced. Taste, and add more salt and/or pepper if needed.

  3. To serve, portion the pasta into serving bowls and drizzle a couple of teaspoons of garlic basil oil over each bowl. Pass more Parmesan with a grater at the table.

Adapted from recipes by Scott Conant of Scarpetta and Jaden Hair of Steamy Kitchen Photo credit: Shutterstock