Best, Easiest Homemade Pizza Ever

Best Easiest Homemade Pizza Ever

The best and easiest homemade pizza ever? Really?

I know, it’s a bold statement. And if it was my own recipe, I’d have to be pretty full of myself to say it. But, since it’s not my recipe, but that of one of the most talented pizza makers in the country (world?), I know it to be true.

I’d gotten out of the habit of making my own pizza dough of late. What, with so many shops selling pretty solid options — from my lovely, local Canyon Market to Trader Joe’s — I wondered if it was worth the effort (and patted myself on the back for making my own at all rather than speed dialing Dominos).

But low and behold, just days after sinking my teeth into a heavenly Margarita pie at CO, a cozy New York eatery, the very chef, Jim Lahey, behind that very pizza, published his very recipe on Food52, one of the most reliable websites I know for excellent eats.

The recipe is officially called:

Jim Lahey’s No Knead Pizza

Here’s what’s involved.


Easiest Pizza Dough EVER!

How easy is that? No fancy flour, no wondering if the water temperature is just right to activate the yeast, no sticky, kneading mess. It’s certainly quicker than walking to the market and buying dough. Plus, unlike store bought, which I’ve found to be stubborn to work, this one is pretty maleable.


Best Easiest Homemade Pizza Ever

A couple of things to keep in mind.

6 Tips for Making Homemade Pizza

1. Get a Pizza Stone

Owning a pizza stone is the best way to get that super crispy texture to your crust. It’s a small investment that you will have FOREVER (mine was a wedding gift) and is easy to store alongside your baking sheets or cutting boards

2) A Pizza Peel Helps, Too.

That’s the wooden board with a handle you see at pizzerias which allows you to slip the pie right onto the pizza stone with one swift move. If you don’t have either peel or stone, you can make this on an ordinary cookie sheet, just be sure your oven is piping hot.

These six tips can help you make the most delicious homemade pizza ever! Click To Tweet

3) Consider Cutting Down on the Cheese

I used about one-third less Mozzarella and half the Parmesan called for in the recipe. To me, it was still plenty cheesy.

4) Have Fun With Toppings!

We played around with toppings in addition to plain cheese — olives, arugula, spinach, prosciutto.

5) Keep the Heat Consistent

The oven temperature remained at 500 degrees. We didn’t incorporate the broiler as is suggested in the recipe (too complicated for our crew) and the pizza was still over the top.

6) Serve Delicious Sides

We found the recipe made enough for our family of five, plus slices leftover for lunch boxes the next day. Keep in mind, I served the pizza with both a generous salad and a side of roasted asparagus. This assured we weren’t just filling up on the delicious pie, but balancing all that cheesy goodness with plenty of green stuff. Red wine helped the grown ups wash it all down; we need our antioxidants and phytochemicals, people!

Sidenote: If you’re looking for a speedy weeknight pizza, check out my Spinach and Prosciutto Lavash Pizza (oven to table in 15 minutes).

photo credit: shutterstock


05.04.2012 at7:31 AM #

Catherine McCord

My kids would eat pizza 7 nights a week if I let them. This looks delicious!

05.04.2012 at7:31 AM #

Katie Morford

Hi Catherine. Ditto on the pizza 7 nights a week!

05.04.2012 at10:23 AM #


Thanks, Katie! We’ve been making pizza but buying the dough from Bi-Rite or Whole Foods. Frances and I will give this a try.

05.04.2012 at10:23 AM #

Katie Morford

Christine, let me know how it goes with this.

06.27.2013 at11:24 AM #


Did you let the dough sit for 18 HOURS?! Just wondering because that is what the recipe says and i thought that was a really long time. let me know thanks. Love the site!

06.27.2013 at11:24 AM #

Katie Morford

Yes, 18 hours. The recipes requires a bit of advance notice, but very little work!

06.28.2013 at3:00 PM #


Didn’t the dough sit for 18 hours but still came out unbelievable!! Best pizza ever! thanks for posting.

08.03.2013 at12:59 PM #


made me sick!

05.12.2014 at12:52 PM #


BEST PIZZA EVER!! super easy to make, healthier than the greasy pizza at the restaurant and but has the restaurant quality taste! The crust turns out perfect. Just follow the recipe and you’re golden 🙂

05.12.2014 at12:52 PM #


BEST PIZZA EVER!! super easy to make, healthier than the greasy pizza at the restaurant but has the restaurant quality taste! The crust turns out perfect. Just follow the recipe and you’re golden 🙂

05.12.2014 at12:52 PM #

Katie Morford

Agreed. It’s magic.

02.27.2019 at3:28 AM #

Boyd Kobe

Homemade pizza dough is the best! I love this easy recipe! Thank you.

05.24.2020 at8:58 AM #

Kara E

How do you make pizza for your family and have everyone sit down together and eat at the same time? I never make it because I’m in the kitchen making pizza after pizza while they sit and eat.

05.24.2020 at8:58 AM #

Katie Morford

Hi Kara,

One thought is to do one big, sheet-pan pizza on a well-oiled baking sheet. I’ve been doing that lately. I’ve also taught everyone else in the house how to make it, so we take turns.

Post Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *